January 9, 2008 7:10 AM PST

Sony bows $200 Blu-ray player

by Matthew Elliott

New low: a $200 Blu-ray drive.

(Credit: Sony Electronics Inc.)

Funai announced a standalone Blu-ray player that will dip below the $300 mark when it's released next quarter, but if you've got a PC that's up to the challenge, Sony's got an internal Serial ATA Blu-ray drive that will do the trick for even less. The BDU-X10S drive will cost $199.99 when Sony starts shipping it next month (preorder it here). This BD-ROM (that's read, not write) drive comes bundled with CyberLink PowerDVD BD Edition for playing Blu-ray discs in MPEG-2 or H.264 format. It'll also play DVDs and CDs and will work with XP and Vista PCs.

Matt Elliott, a CNET editor since 2000, heads up coverage of computer hardware, from desktops and laptops to their assorted components and peripherals. Prior to joining CNET, he worked for PC Magazine. When not writing about computers and wrestling with their shipping boxes, he likes shooting with his Nikon D50 camera. Matt is also skilled with a tape gun. E-mail Matt.
Recent posts from CES 2008
CES 2008: Home audio wrap-up
CES 2008: Home video wrap-up
CES 2008 HDTV wrap-up
Computers and hardware CES 2008 wrap-up
Emerging technologies CES 2008 wrap-up
Car Tech CES 2008 wrap-up
CES 2008: MP3 and PVP wrap-up
Cell phones and smartphones CES 2008 wrap-up
Add a Comment (Log in or register) Showing 1 of 2 pages (37 Comments)
by rockymtnbri January 9, 2008 9:38 AM PST
I plan to pick one of these up as soon as they're available!
Reply to this comment
by sanenazok January 9, 2008 11:39 AM PST
I would think about this, but only if these had DVD writing (not bluRay, of course, just standard DVD)
Reply to this comment
by Leria January 10, 2008 4:01 PM PST
I have to agree with the "Only if this has DVD writing thing!" though I would also say "Only if it has Blu-Ray writing as well! I want to be able to write to Blu-Ray disks with a player that is going to cost me $200 dollars, period and done with. Otherwise, it is too expensive for what you get.
by batman823 January 11, 2008 9:24 AM PST
Just leave the DVDRW drive that you have in your computer for writing discs, problem solved. I'd be more worried about the BluRay ripping and burning, if that's what you want to accomplish
by dirty55409 January 9, 2008 1:13 PM PST
I'll wait for the BD-R drive to drop in price... this drive/price is a good sign of things to come though.
Reply to this comment
by hddvdfan January 9, 2008 2:21 PM PST
I think that LG has a better deal, it has a blue ray drive that can also read hd dvd discs, and in come with dvd writer and ligth script, so i think is better that sony, and sony alwasy give things that are the same that the others competitors but a higher price, and try to said that is better with awesone advertisements.
by lorax1284 January 9, 2008 6:03 PM PST
With Warner Home Video's recent announcement, It may be moot, but LG sells a dual format HD DVD / BD reader (not writer) that does write DVD-RW / DL etc. and comes with Cyberlink Power DVD. It's ~$250 right now... dual format drives may be a moot point now, but if HD-DVD does die, there may be some excellent deals on HDDVD movies, so having a drive that will play them may be handy.
Reply to this comment
by wasabi1000 January 10, 2008 5:24 AM PST
oh snap!!
Reply to this comment
by teachandfly January 10, 2008 7:07 AM PST
You know it?s funny this whole debate. I don?t know why we are even having a HD/BR war if they haven?t noticed the public doesn?t really want it. If I never own another DVD I will be happy, I want to be able to download my content. I can watch HD movies though my cable company, on demand or on X-Box live. I would rather download my next HD movie and keep it on a hard drive, then bring it up from my home network in any room of the house, then to be stuck with a player hooked up to one TV. If you have kids, you will find out that no disk is safe I have had to buy Cinderella 3 times because the disk gets ruined, for the love of it let me download it, put it on a hard drive, if my car could have a hard drive in it and just send it to it?s hard drive I could take all my movies with me in the car and never have to change them while driving would be great, oh yeah not to mention stoping the complaints that the movie isn?t working right. So why will I never run and get one of these players, I will wait to download it, so why continue the debate.
Reply to this comment
by woodygg January 11, 2008 7:44 AM PST
you may feel that way, but a lot of people want to own the movie (i'm not one of them... but you'd be amazed) - especially that others might feel differently than you apparantly.
by batman823 January 11, 2008 9:28 AM PST
Why don't you try this. DON'T change the movies while driving if that's not what you want to do. Just pay attention to the road instead of trying to kill your kids, or somebody else for that matter.

But I completely see your point and agree about the silly format war.
by Soupcc January 11, 2008 11:04 AM PST
Well I get so sick of people talking about they want their content downloadable. How many HD movies do you think you are going to get on a Hard Drive. I have a collection of over 400 standard DVD and I don't think I can get that collection on a Hard Drive or many Hard Drives. Now if you talking about HD, the avg. person may have a 200 GB hard drive. HD movies may be 30-50 GB for one movie. Do the math.
by KTate70 January 10, 2008 8:18 AM PST
Ahh... The English language and all its quirks! (Remember: They're over there with their friends.)
Reply to this comment
by graviz January 10, 2008 10:05 AM PST
As of right now most consumers who are buying Blu Ray & HD Dvd are people who realy care about home theater. This really goes without saying. Most people who are audiofiles or videofiles will not use a computer for their dvd playing needs (and yes I understand a reciever has a computer in it....I just thought I would eliminate that point). Unless you have a media center pc or a homemade one it "typically" won't have the proper connections for hooking it up to a new tv and surround sound system. I've invested in a HD dvd player for my XBOX 360 and it works great (only $150). I personally think my HD dvd collection will end up like my SACD & Dvd audio collection, yet I don't think Blu Ray will win either. I think people who think downloading movies will win is a joke. It may be a good solution for renting, however owning most people want something they can hold. If I was a betting man, and I am, I would put money on the flash memory format they are developing.
Reply to this comment
by rdgadz January 11, 2008 10:11 AM PST
... oh and CDs for music are totally winning over iTunes/Rhapsody/Zune/etc...

that should be a perfect example of where video is headed
by jomoelle January 10, 2008 10:37 AM PST
Ok i have a question for all off u electronic buffs out there but im not sure if youll ko the answer. I am using a HP A1630N pretty decient computer i upgraded to a Nvidia 8600GT and I was wondering when I one of these babies will I be very disapointed with the quaility if I run DVI-HDMI to my 40" sony LCD or should I invest in a new video card with HDMI-Out?
Reply to this comment
by graviz January 10, 2008 10:50 AM PST
You won't notice a significant difference between DVI-HDMI and straight HDMI out. Digital is digital for the most part. I don't know that paticular model # however the only thing that could really hurt the playback quality is the ram & cpu speed (playback lag).
by Iceman35 January 11, 2008 4:41 AM PST
Yes by all means.
by j_a_s_p_e_r January 11, 2008 1:09 PM PST
DVI has an equivalent image signal to HDMI. HDMI adds audio and encryption. The problem is some movies will only play over HDMI (copy protection)
by layclerk January 10, 2008 10:47 AM PST
HAHA. I'm glad to know I'm not the only spelling maven on this site. Don't you just love it when people reply sarcastically? It only shows how wrong they know they are. Nothing has changed from when I was in school, and all the morons and dumb jocks resented me for my superior command of the language.
Reply to this comment
by Hiwayman January 11, 2008 8:59 AM PST
While spelling seems to be an increasing challenge to most Americans these days, why don't we keep the self-congratulating nonsense to sites that specialize in priggish behavior, and keep the comments on this site focused on the relative merits of technology? I'm sorry you had a rough time in high school. Get over it. Now, back to our Blu-Ray v. HD discussion.....
by PHXHoward January 10, 2008 11:50 AM PST
DVI -> HDMI is the same as HDMI except that you don't get the audio on the same cable. Your PC probably has an optical out on it already. Make sure that your video card has HDCP on the DVI port or you will be limited.
Reply to this comment
by epitone January 10, 2008 12:15 PM PST
That's great, but shouldn't Sony try to fix their $300 BD player before they cut even more corners to release a cheaper one? From everything I hear, the S300 is riddled with problems (incompatibility, freezing, slow load times, etc.)... as are pretty much all the other affordable standalone BD players. Except the PS3, of course, which I happily picked up the other day.
Reply to this comment
by TrueLeo January 10, 2008 12:47 PM PST
well, i have to say, if you arent technology savy to handle complicated drives, just like a huge percentage of the people in world, and very price oriented, again a huge percentage (even bigger). i applaud this product, i think its cheap and simple enough for people who are not tech savy to say "this plays blu-rays disc from your computer". instead of other players that may say "this is a BR/HD-rom, that reads and writes. also it has powerDVD, formatted for 98, 2000, XP, vista, and 40 different OS. and its makes coffee in the mornings, and tucks you in at night, AND has power windows." alot of people i work with wouldnt know what 90% of this stuff means. lol all im saying is its fairly simple and cheap. very good buy for the average consumer and a good price for a Blu-ray player.
Reply to this comment
by TrueLeo January 10, 2008 12:49 PM PST
and id like to add people that arent into game systems too. to pick up and PS3(which i do own), nor a X-box, to go into high-def.
Reply to this comment
by batman823 January 11, 2008 9:36 AM PST
This is great for those people you mention. I think it's especially great for those who have noticed the VGA output the video card has. Most of the higher-end Vcards have two of them. Or you can easily and inexpensively add another video card so you can play HD movies on the big TV, run your cable through the PC that way too(with media center), use your computers XP or VISTA on the other moniter and not lose any functionality, etc....
by lspaiser January 10, 2008 3:48 PM PST
Don't know what all this excitement is over BD players is. I recently bought a Samsung 1400 for $280 at Costco. Plays BDs fine, although response to control commands is a bit slow. So what! (See my comments on this product).
Reply to this comment
by robertsantos January 10, 2008 9:06 PM PST
BFD! Why wait?

LITE-ON Black 12X DVD-ROM 32X CD-ROM SATA Blu-ray DVD-ROM Drive Model DH-4O1S-11 - OEM
Free Philips 20X burner w/ combo purchase, ends 1/15
$189.99
Free 3 Business Day Shipping

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16827106227
Reply to this comment
by make_or_break January 11, 2008 7:01 AM PST
Morons = spelling and grammer Nazis who ONLY see fit to comment on those aspects of a posted comment. If that's all you can add to the discussion, then I rather put up with the ramblin', bumblin', mistake-laden postings...at least they UNDERSTAND the topic at hand, even if their thoughts are as clear as mud.

As for said topic at hand...finally affordable devices that DOESN'T lock up a gaming console into a either-or scenario (kids wanna play games...parents want to watch a movie, or vice-versa). OTOH, it's not a stand-alone unit like Toshiba builds that plugs into a home entertainment system [i]without[/i] the extraneous need for a computer (commenting specifically on the Sony ROM drive). As for the Funai device...it's headed in the right direction...but whoTF is Funai, other than a manufacturer of bottom-feeder electronics that only discount general merchandise stores carry? Where's Pioneer? Where's Panasonic?

In the end, I like several others here still question whether or not it's all moot. Disc delivery is going the way of the dodo bird. It's too wasteful of resources, even when it's mail ordered (somebody will have to pay for the fuel to get it into your device, not to mention all the manufacturing and distribution costs involved), and doesn't have the appeal for the 'gotta-have-it-yesterday' mentality. And like too many other consumers, I still think standard DVD upscaled is "good enough" (even if the actual content isn't), if this whole principle of disc delivery is bought into. As soon as HD-DVD discs begin disappearing from retailers, will Blu-ray studios really reduce their wares to compete with the older format, or will they continue to position themselves as a 'premier' branding of the same content?

Personally I'd rather count on the download alternative, particularly since I've waited this long already. But it's at least still good that prices on the drives are FINALLY below $200. Of course if [i]Sony[/i] does it, then others will be even cheaper still.
Reply to this comment
by megustansalchichas January 11, 2008 11:16 AM PST
huh huh huuh, you said 'grammer'
by Riverledge January 11, 2008 7:42 PM PST
WHO IS FUNAI? Actually a highly regarded Japanese brand name; but rarely seen in the USA. They also seem to sponsor Boston Red Sox pitcher DICE-K,
for some reason, in their Japanese commercials, from what I hear.

I'd scoop up a SONY PLAYSTATION 3, if I were you.

Best wishes, River.
by daviddyer January 11, 2008 12:15 PM PST
This screams Bluray Xbox360 add-on to me. It's the same price as the HDDVD add-on when it first came out.
Reply to this comment
by alaskancrab January 11, 2008 2:09 PM PST
My only concern about this product is that a lot of people will probably buy this item thinking their "new" computer will be able to handle the load. But if you take a peak at c-net's/gamespot CES coverage you'll see NVIDIA only really qualifies the Geforce 8600GT and above as realistically capable of handling a 1080p signal. I own an 8800 GTS and my machine just barely gets by, and god forbid the machine tries to do something that requires further resources other than decompressing the stream. As Nvidia puts it "None of the PC's in 2007 were made or advertised as High Def".
Reply to this comment
by JoeZ14 January 11, 2008 2:54 PM PST
i never had a problem with dvds, and i dont think i will. this bluray vs hddvd thing , i cant say i care about lol
Reply to this comment
Showing 1 of 2 pages (37 Comments)
advertisement

CES awards and nominees

Best of CES, 2009

Best of CES and People's Voice Award

Since 2006, CNET has presented the Best of CES Awards, given to the top product in 10 categories as well as one coveted Best in Show award. See the gadgets that topped our list for this year, and find out the People's Voice winner, decided by more than 10,000 member votes.

LATEST FROM MACWORLD

Report: Social Security numbers can be predicted

Posted by Elinor Mills July 6, 2009 5:59 PM PDT

When gaming communities go wrong

Posted by Dave Rosenberg July 6, 2009 5:44 PM PDT

Walkman versus the rest--Ask the Editors

Posted by Jasmine France July 6, 2009 5:42 PM PDT
See our full Macworld coverage

RSS FEEDS