January 7, 2008 11:00 AM PST

EchoStar TR-50: HD DVR for the antenna crowd

by John P. Falcone
  • Font size
  • Print
  • 43 comments

EchoStar TR-50 HD DVR

EchoStar TR-50: An HD DVR for those without cable or satellite

(Credit: EchoStar)

If you think everybody has cable or satellite, you couldn't be more wrong. In fact, if you live in an area that's well-served by digital broadcasters, now's a better time than ever to get your TV over the air (or "OTA," as the cool kids say): yeah, you get only a handful of channels, but they're in crystal-clear digital quality--DVD quality at "worst," uncompressed high-definition at best. The problem--as we're reminded by many an e-mailer--is that there just isn't a good DVR solution for the rabbit-ears crowd, especially if you prefer high-def. (You can opt for a TiVo HD, but you'd still have to pay a monthly fee for their programming guide.) But that may finally be changing, thanks to the EchoStar TR-50. For all intents and purposes, the TR-50 takes many of the features found on Dish Networks' excellent satellite DVRs (such as the ViP622 and 722) and brings them to antenna-based TV viewers.

The unit offers ATSC and NTSC tuners, so it can view and record over-the-air HD digital, standard digital, and analog channels. Dual tuner action means you can watch (and record) one live channel while simultaneously recording a second--or record two channels while playing back a previously recorded show. There's also full control over live TV, including rewind, pause, slow motion, 10-second "instant replay," and--for recordings--30-second skip. The TR-50 also sports a 7-day electronic program guide (using over-the-air metadata on the digital band), which should eliminate the pesky VCR-style manual "timer recordings" (you remember: "8:00-9:00 p.m. / Thursdays / channel 4"). The box also has a full range of outputs, including component and HDMI (480i, 480p, 720p, 1080i resolutions supported), as well as standard-def composite and RF outputs for older TVs. Dish hasn't yet specified the internal hard drive size, but the USB 2.0 connector will ensure expandable storage. Perhaps most interestingly, the TR-50 includes an Ethernet port and the ability to decode MPEG-4 video, and EchoStar touts its ability to "access premium Internet-based TV programming via broadband Internet," as well as "DVR management and timer creation via Internet"--though the timeframe for such features wasn't disclosed. Likewise, the exact release date and pricing information remain a mystery. But if it's affordable--and lacks TiVo's monthly fee--the TR-50 may be the perfect fit for TV viewers without satellite or cable who still want to enjoy HD programming on their own schedule.

Separately, EchoStar also announced the TR-40. That model is merely a digital set-top box (no DVR). It will let analog TV owners (or those with HD monitors that lack a tuner) receive digital and high-def signals over the air--a necessity after the scheduled February 2009 analog TV shutdown.

John P. Falcone covers home theater and network entertainment products. He's been writing for CNET since 2002.
Recent posts from CES 2008
CES 2008: Home audio wrap-up
CES 2008: Home video wrap-up
CES 2008 HDTV wrap-up
Computers and hardware CES 2008 wrap-up
Emerging technologies CES 2008 wrap-up
Car Tech CES 2008 wrap-up
CES 2008: MP3 and PVP wrap-up
Cell phones and smartphones CES 2008 wrap-up
Add a Comment (Log in or register) Showing 1 of 2 pages (43 Comments)
by peterj_1992 January 8, 2008 6:49 PM PST
Yes! Eversince we've gotten our samsung HDTV and home theatre system (last year boxing day), I've been constantly looking and dvd/hdd recorders and none of them seemed to have an atsc tuner. I was extremely suprised when a few months ago stores just stopped selling them (if someone can explain that to me that would be helpful), and this is just what I've been looking for! (with the absence of a dvd burner.) I just hope they wont have a monthly fee like tivo, because i hate tivo
Reply to this comment
by ricardoc66 February 7, 2008 2:22 PM PST
Actually the Toshiba DVR650 has both ATSC and NTSC tuners and it retailing for under $30 0 at any of the major e-tailers.<br /><br /><a class="jive-link-external" href="http://www.tacp.toshiba.com/dvr/product.asp?model=d-vr650" target="_newWindow">http://www.tacp.toshiba.com/dvr/product.asp?model=d-vr650</a><br /><br />It's not the only one in this DVD-Recorder segement with ATSC...<br /><br /><a class="jive-link-external" href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DVD_recorder#Comparison_of_2007_ATSC_DVD_recorders_in_U.S.A" target="_newWindow">http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DVD_recorder#Comparison_of_2007_ATSC_DVD_recorders_in_U.S.A</a>.
by notuptodate January 11, 2008 6:52 AM PST
For those of us in "OTA" land and old TV's - this looks great - for my 1.5 hrs. a day of TV viewing - I hope they price it next year so I can afford 1 for each TV ? or just need 1 for the house (4 TV's)
Reply to this comment
by Andymanout January 11, 2008 3:15 PM PST
All things are possible with a network installed into your home. Whether it is wireless or hard wired, you can have one recorder serving the entire home. Its all in the (Obligatory catch phrase used here) Connectivity you have in your home. Fear not! Open your check book and head over to your local electronics supplier, if your handy. If you dont know RG from Cat 6 then call a qualified installer.<br /><br />Andyman Out!
by BiffSedgewick January 11, 2008 8:04 AM PST
VCR's should have naturally migrated to this type of box instead of paying a chunk of change for a box, then a load it with pay services that Tivo and Replay offered. The VCR+ code should have been added to the box just like the VCR days and a start, stop time for recording, then an option to add a premium service like TV guide for even easier recording mgmt. All Rights Reserved, Tivo, Replay, etc. Most people are likely to pay for services like that, instead saving money for retirement. You can't walk out your door today and not be tempted with all kinds of pay for services.
Reply to this comment
by Andymanout January 11, 2008 3:22 PM PST
As true a statement as can be uttered, but where is the profit in that? Unfortunately the manufacturers of electronics have been bitten by the wall street bug. The days of the thirty year TV and fair and equitable decisions be made by all the electronic manufacturers are gone. We have to hope Americans and their like minded bretheren will stop buying the cheapest solution when in come to their purchases and start demanding quality products again. Spread the word on that and some day maybe....<br /><br />Andyman Out!
by brittonv January 11, 2008 8:30 AM PST
I would have to say Windows Media Center Blows this away.
Reply to this comment
by Andymanout January 11, 2008 3:25 PM PST
Hey brittonv, could you elaborate on that claim? I have heard some negatives re: vista and media center. <br /><br />Andyman Out!
Reply to this comment
by Actualeng January 11, 2008 7:04 PM PST
It's not meant to compare with a home theatre PC setup.<br /><br />Sounds like a great box for the OTA folks like myself. Ethernet and USB storage are nice touches great for getting files in and out of the box. <br /><br />Dvico already makes a TVIX box that can do this with an optional ATSC tuner but it's not very polished and cannot record and watch at the same time. I'm hoping this echostar is a more polished version of the TVIX.
by RedHedd January 12, 2008 10:00 AM PST
I want it! Where/when can I get it?
Reply to this comment
by photog_7 January 12, 2008 12:48 PM PST
Monthly fees are a part of EchoStar's DNA. I doubt this will be any different.
Reply to this comment
by send2rick1 January 12, 2008 2:33 PM PST
It does make you wonder who is paying for the program guide if the user is not. Will there be advertising for that? Not that I would mind; if I could get TiVo type features for free. But if the service is unsuccessful and stops; will I still be able to program it manually like a VCR or will I be left with an expensive paper weight?<br /><br />This link reveals the HD size "250GB"<br /><a class="jive-link-external" href="http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showthread.php?t=972197" target="_newWindow">http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showthread.php?t=972197</a><br /><br />This link (video of it) states that software updates can be downloaded through the ethernet port. So will there be charges for that?<br /><a class="jive-link-external" href="http://www.cnettv.com/9742-1_53-31894.html" target="_newWindow">http://www.cnettv.com/9742-1_53-31894.html</a><br /><br />If you are listening Echostar; a Firwire port would be nice.<br /><br />Also wondering if the hard drive will show up on a network through the ethernet port on my computer and what operating system it uses; Linux like most of the others? Anyone know?
Reply to this comment
by brittonv January 14, 2008 9:15 AM PST
I have a couple of HD Tuners in my XP Media center PC. I have a 1.5 TB Drive and can watch what ever I want where ever I want (Where ever I have an Xbox that is)<br /><br />I can't speak to Vista, as I haven't downgraded yet.
Reply to this comment
by kennlee April 19, 2008 10:08 AM PDT
What kind of HD tuners do you have that allows you to watch full HD playback? Even the latest Hauppauge and ATI cards don't allow this kind of resolution.
by Tvwonderman January 23, 2008 8:49 AM PST
I think this is a great innovation, and will sell well if priced right. However, regarding "there just isn't a good DVR solution for the rabbit-ears crowd", there actually is a very good solution, and it's right under the nose of a lot of people. Microsoft Media Center is a fabulous DVR and overall media access solution. The Echostar box definitely has the advantage of being a dedicated box nicely packaged as an appliance, and it's a great solution. But for those who seek all that and more, and who are willing to put a tuner in their PC and connect it to their TV either direct or via an extender, Media Center is a great option. with Media Center, I run full HD 1920x1080, and along with my 14 channels of free HD from my antenna (complete with 5.1 audio, and 25+ total channels), I get a fantastic full-blown EPG, movie posters/ratings/reviews, full DVR with advanced features like keyword and future DVR scheduling, full uncompressed signal, and can access all my home videos, all my music, as well as my subscription music service and internet video, Yahoo Sports for MCE, weather, and many other apps built for the platform. I can record two HD shows while watching a third recorded HD show. And I can access all this content from anywhere in the house, or across the internet. And other than the cost of the PC itself and some setup time, all this is *completely free*. That's hard to beat!
Reply to this comment
by supersavermom January 30, 2008 5:49 AM PST
Tvwonderman,<br />Can you tell me exactly what I need to buy in order to have the same setup as you? Keep in mind I am a Mom (40+ in age), who is trying to cut our household budget. We have an antenna, but our currently paying for DISH satellite monthly. You knowledge is greatly appreciated!
by brettsherm March 30, 2008 9:35 AM PDT
As a dedicated Media Center user (actually Snapstream), I have to say there is a hidden cost to computer-based PVR's too. That is the cost of keeping a computer on 24 hours a day 365 days a year. I've calculated that the 150 watts it uses costs me $240 a year in electricity alone. I'm not sure I'll go for a solution like the TR-50 or TiVO. But it sure would save a lot of money in electricity. And it makes the monthly fee of a TiVO a wash. The hardware and software adds up and gets to be a lot more expensive than you might think. I do like the flexibility of the computer PVR. But it certainly is no cost saver.
by Bowhunter8 February 4, 2009 6:46 AM PST
To Bretsherm's point about cost to power a PC. One would also need to power the TIVO. IMO the cost may be a bit lower than a hi-power pc, but it is still there.
by Holyroller111 March 9, 2008 9:01 PM PDT
I'm anciously awaiting this unit,i hope it lives up to my expectations which are high after owning five other dvr's,they all have their problems and each has their avantages, the BIGGEST disadvantage of this one will be if Echostar makes You pay for the Epg,cause if they do then i won't buy. Echostar listen- we already have tivo-if you want to kill tivo then you better not make us pay, you will lose!
Reply to this comment
by pocorock August 25, 2008 8:48 AM PDT
OTA Digital channels have their EPG built into them. There is no need to pay for the EPG as the broadcaster supplies them. This is a great feature built in.<br />I can't wait for this item to hit the market. <br />I know window media center is a great product, but I don't like the idea of having my computer running just to watch TV.
by fgaipa March 14, 2008 11:07 AM PDT
Currently I have an analog no-cable-box Comcast account, but all the would-be over-the-air-stations there in the line. My Samsung's QAM tuner pulls them in, but I have no way to time-shift them.<br /><br />Will the Echostar be able to do this for me?<br /><br />Satellite's not an option due to surrounding four and five story buildings (even a powered indoor hd antenna gets nothing), and Comcast's dvr rental would be inanely expensive and widely despised.
Reply to this comment
by brettsherm March 30, 2008 9:35 AM PDT
As a dedicated Media Center user (actually Snapstream), I have to say there is a hidden cost to computer-based PVR's too. That is the cost of keeping a computer on 24 hours a day 365 days a year. I've calculated that the 150 watts it uses costs me $240 a year in electricity alone. I'm not sure I'll go for a solution like the TR-50 or TiVO. But it sure would save a lot of money in electricity. And it makes the monthly fee of a TiVO a wash. The hardware and software adds up and gets to be a lot more expensive than you might think. I do like the flexibility of the computer PVR. But it certainly is no cost saver.
Reply to this comment
by userocnet March 30, 2008 1:20 PM PDT
Forget microsoft vista media center crap. Try Linux/MythTV for free!<br /><br />Also, let your computer sleep in-between recording programs. It won't use much electricity.
Reply to this comment
by AJShadow June 12, 2008 7:10 PM PDT
I live in the SF Bay Area where OTA reception ranges anywhere from good to great (unless you live on the other side of the Oakland Hills, like Danville, San Ramon, Dublin etc), so when I heard about this option as a replacement to my Panasonic DVR, I was very happy, but cautious. <br /><br />After speaking with Panasonic Customer Service I discovered that my DMR-ES20 will not work without a digital converter after Feb. 2009 - regardless of my built in digital converter in my plasma TV. They told me that I would need a digital converter to record any of the digital stations. <br /><br />I'm guessing the connections to make this work would be:<br /><br /> 1. Antenna wire into the converter IN port<br /> 2. Jumper cable from the OUT port of the converter box to the IN port of the DVR<br /> 3. Jumper cable from the OUT port of the DVR to the IN port of the TV.<br /> 4. Then the converter box would have to be ON at all times to record.<br /><br />Does anyone out there know if I am on the right track?<br /><br />My 3rd option is to buy the Panasonic DMR-EZ28.
Reply to this comment
by almost_silent June 16, 2008 4:07 PM PDT
I can't say wheter what you want to do will work or not. At this point there isn't much available on the TR-50. <br /><br />However, the information on the DISH Network website for the DTVPAL ATSC Coupon Eligible Digital Converter says it has an event timer for recording to VCR's etc.. It goes on sale the week of June 23, according to the website I've been planning to buy from. If you don't really want a DVR, perhaps it would be enough.
Reply to this comment
by DrBill64 June 20, 2008 6:13 PM PDT
Could you please E-mail the link about the Tr-50 and 40 going on Sale?
by Schneiderdriver August 6, 2008 12:16 AM PDT
Is this thing ever actually going to be available? July has come and gone, and I don't believe it has been released yet.
Reply to this comment
by cnt21 September 1, 2008 3:42 PM PDT
I have waited for years for a DVR for my antenna lifestyle. I hate DVD's so I don't want to buy a DVD recorder and my VCR won't work soon. I won't be buying the junk converter box ( due to their limitations and complications) either, so now I have to buy new TV's. Cable is too expensive .What happened to more simple days, technology is getting worse in my opinion.
Reply to this comment
by ko220 September 14, 2008 7:56 AM PDT
Your VCR's will work fine. From what I understand, all you have to do is route your converter box into the VCR and set your VCR to Channel 3 to record. You just won't be able to record one channel and watch another, unless you also have a separate converter box for the TV just to do that. I've been doing a boatload of research on this.
by intanet September 10, 2008 7:14 PM PDT
I just wrote Echostar today (Sept 10, 08) and this was their response:<br /><br />"Hello.<br /><br />Just recently announced, the TR50 will be sold as the DTVPal DVR, and will be available around Thanksgiving for a price of $299. It will be available online through DISH Network. At this time we do not have any information on whether the product will be available through retail outlets. An online information site is planned for the near future. Please check back with us as we get closer to the product launch date.<br /><br />Thank you for contacting EchoStar.<br />Regards,<br />EchoStar Sales Team"<br /><br />So much for the $49 price huh.
Reply to this comment
by sandylee1072 September 11, 2008 7:09 AM PDT
Thank you for getting the most up to date information available on the EchoStar TR-50. $299, WOW, alot more then I was hoping. As long as it is not a pay service and will work like my VCRs that will be trash in a few short months. I want to be able to record programs and I currently use 3 VCRs at the hieght of the TV Programing season. Some nights there are shows on 3 different networks at the same time I want to record and watch later. This whole thing sucks.
by ko220 September 14, 2008 7:54 AM PDT
I'm really, really looking forward to this, but I think I will wait until the price comes down by at least 100$. Until then, I can make do with a cheaper converter box &#38; just keep using my VCR. They didn't say anything about possible subscriptions - I will NOT pay for a subscription just to be able to record shows.
by Bowhunter8 February 4, 2009 7:13 AM PST
Dish Network has a device for their product with a similar model number for ~$50. That's likely where the ~$50 number came from.
by ChimaC September 26, 2008 1:41 PM PDT
I am sooo ready for this device, hopefully it will won't have any hidden fees associated. Overall, I looked at the media center solution, but that still involves too many signal passes just to watch TV. On the plus side, this really simplifies things in terms of devices, just turn on the TR-50 Box and turn on the TV. The downside with the media center is the PC has to be on, the extender has to be on, the router has to be on, and if the network or PC hangs on you right before a show, you'll most likely be power cycling devices instead of watching TV.
Reply to this comment
Showing 1 of 2 pages (43 Comments)
advertisement

CES awards and nominees

Best of CES, 2009

Best of CES 2009 and
People's Voice Award

Since 2006, CNET has presented the Best of CES Awards, given to the top product in 10 categories as well as one coveted Best in Show award. See the gadgets that topped our list for this year, and find out the People's Voice winner, decided by more than 10,000 member votes.

Now accepting submissions for the 2010 Best of CES Awards.

LATEST FROM MACWORLD

Rafe and Josh debate Google's Buzz

Posted by Rafe Needleman, Josh Lowensohn February 9, 2010 6:10 PM PST

Nissan Juke set to debut in New York

Posted by Wayne Cunningham February 9, 2010 5:49 PM PST

Buick LaCrosse surprises with luxury, value

Posted by Wayne Cunningham February 9, 2010 5:37 PM PST
See our full Macworld coverage

RSS FEEDS